After a night at a motel due to a storm, Belly chooses to be with . She realizes that while Conrad was her first love, Jeremiah is the person who has consistently been there for her. Key Moments

Let me know which you'd like to dive into! Love Triangle - The Summer I Turned Pretty Wiki | Fandom

: After seeing Belly and Jeremiah kiss, Conrad puts on a "sassy" front in the car but ultimately decides to step back to give them space.

: He expresses deep-seated insecurity, worrying he is just a second choice, but he ultimately accepts Belly's decision to fight for their relationship.

between the show's ending and the second book Give you a preview of what happens next based on the books List the soundtrack used in this specific episode

: The tension peaks in the cramped motel room where the brothers are forced to confront their feelings for the same girl.

In the Season 2 finale of The Summer I Turned Pretty , titled Belly finally makes a definitive choice between the Fisher brothers while dealing with the fallout of a heavy year. The Big Decision

: Flashbacks show Susannah’s hope for Belly and Conrad to be together, which adds a layer of guilt and conflict to Belly's decision.