During the exchange at an abandoned location, Neal confirms the Bible is authentic. Just as Maria prepares to kill Neal after the trade, the FBI moves in to arrest her. A Touch of Mystery

The story begins when , a notorious New York mob boss, takes the unusual step of visiting an FBI stakeout to ask for help. Someone has stolen a precious 500-year-old Bible from his church. While Peter is skeptical of the book's supposed supernatural abilities, Neal is intrigued by the legends surrounding it:

Allegedly, no one in the parish where the Bible was kept caught even a cold during the pandemic. The "True Believer"

In Season 1, Episode 3 of , titled " Book of Hours ", FBI Agent Peter Burke and Neal Caffrey are pulled into a case that feels more like a religious quest than a standard federal investigation. The Theft of the "Healing Bible"

The episode ends on an ambiguous note. Despite Peter's staunch rationalism—attributing the parish's health to "germs" and "locked doors"—the Bible is returned to the church. In a final moment, Steve’s dog, Lucy, appears to have made a miraculous recovery, leaving even the most cynical characters wondering if there was some truth to the "Healing Bible" legends.