“Still playing it 5 years later, it certainly is! Best game ever.” Reddit · r/RDR2 · 2 years ago “I have 300 hours now, it's definitely worth it.” Reddit · r/RDR2 · 2 years ago Notable Considerations

: Even in 2023, the game's photorealistic landscapes and environmental detail continue to surpass modern AAA open-world games.

: The 40 to 60-hour story is praised for its emotional range and character relationships, moving beyond simple action to explore the decline of the Wild West.

: Some players find the slow, deliberate movement and long horse rides to be clunky or "dragging" compared to more arcade-style games.