Critics from Vulture and Telltale TV noted that while the show still struggles with its identity, this episode succeeded by letting the characters make high-stakes decisions without getting bogged down in unnecessary "theatrics".
Generally considered one of the stronger, more "tolerable" episodes of the first season.
: A subplot involving Charlotte helping Lily through a period-related "crisis" was highlighted by reviewers at Stylist as a refreshing and realistic take on female adolescence and motherhood. Critical Consensus Reviewer Sentiment Pacing
The sweet, enduring friendship between Carrie and Steve is a standout, providing emotional weight.
: In a pivotal and difficult-to-watch sequence, Miranda finally tells Steve she isn't happy and wants a divorce, confessing her feelings for Che Diaz. While Steve’s gracious reaction was heartbreaking for long-time fans, it propelled Miranda’s new journey forward as she rushed to the airport to surprise Che.
Critics noted a shift toward a more "Sex and the City" vibe, particularly in the episode's closing scenes.
“And Just Like That” Season 3 Episode 9 Recap: Present Tense
